This week we were introduced to a poem
called “The History Teacher”, by Billy Collins, that showed a history teacher
teaching his students about disastrous events; Instead of telling the kids the
truth about what really happened, he completely changed them. Even after
expending all his effort trying to maintain his students’ innocence, at recess
they still went out and tormented other children on the playground. The teacher
had good intentions; I mean everyone wants to keep his/her kids pure and safe
right? But, at some point these truths will reveal themselves to these kids and
they will be hit hard with the hand of reality. Children should learn about
historic events, even the horrible ones. I know somebody will question, “Should
we really teach first graders about the slaughter of millions of Jews during
the Holocaust?” but it is not necessary to tell them the full extent of what
happened, teachers can just merely say that many Jewish people died because a
mean Nazi didn’t like them. They will still somewhat comprehend what happened. We need to face our demons in order to learn from
them, how could we stay away from our mistakes in the past if we didn’t know
they happened? We would end up doing the same thing as our ancestors did. It is
better to start learning about these event at a young age.
I really liked you "face your demons" quote and I completely agree with you. I think the history teacher completely changed the truth rather than just euphemizing it. At such a young age you can still teach them the truth but just skip the gory details. MAGNIFICENT POST!:)
ReplyDeleteI agree with 'facing demons' because Collins very effectively proved the point that if kids don't learn about the past they can't learn from it! The kids were beating up the other kids at recess because they didn't understand why that behavior was wrong! The teacher tried so desperately to create a utopia, and fell short. :( sad poem, silly poem, oxymoron.
ReplyDeleteGood post. It's hard to tell when it's the right age or time to reveal the truth even if it means to shed innocence. You say that we must learn at a early age; however, would you tell your own child about disturbing truths of life like cancer and drugs and all those bad stuff or would you postpone the truth so that your kid can enjoy being a kid? It's truly hard to know the right time!
ReplyDelete